The Conceptual Crisis of Private
Property as a Crisis in Practice
A Screenshot by Robert Luxemburg
--------------------------------
crisis.png crisis.php crisis.txt
--------------------------------
documentation press order e-mail


ABSTRACT
--------

"The Conceptual Crisis of Private Property as a Crisis in Practice" is a
screenshot (crisis.png) that shows, among various other things, the source code
of a piece of software (crisis.php) and its documentation (crisis.txt). The
code, once typed up and executed, will transform the screenshot into the full
text of Neal Stephenson's novel "Cryptonomicon".

"The Conceptual Crisis of Private Property as a Crisis in Practice" is not an
actual, but a virtual computer program: an image of piece of software that still
has to be created by copying, saving and running its source code. While the
screenshot may be the "intellectual property" of Robert Luxemburg, the program
itself is free software and may be redistributed and/or modified under the terms
of the GNU General Public License.

"The Conceptual Crisis of Private Property as a Crisis in Practice" is part of a
series of copyright circumvention devices - walser.php (http://textz.com/trash),
pngreader (http://pngreader.gnutenberg.net) - that try to exploit the structural
flaws in the concept of "intellectual property". It is intended to practically
illustrate the assumption that digital data will always escape copyright
protection and that "digital rights" will never be "manageable".

"The Conceptual Crisis of Private Property as a Crisis in Practice" also serves
as proof of concept for a universal cryptographic method to transform any
digital content into whatever copyrighted work. The algorithm is not limited to
image-to-text transformation, but could as well transform a digital video (in
which a similar script would be shown, read or otherwise presented) into a video
editing software suite.

"The Conceptual Crisis of Private Property as a Crisis in Practice" was
nominated for the Transmediale Software Award 2004 and the Werkleitz Award 2004.
The work is available as an edition of 10 digital prints (51.2 x 38.4 cm,
signed, $200 unframed, $250 framed, plus shipping), as an edition of 100 CDs
(Win/Mac/Linux/Unix, signed, $20 plus shipping) and on file sharing networks
(unlimited number of copies, unsigned, free).


F.A.Q.
------

Q: How does it work?
A: The source code is open, so find out yourself.

Q: What's up with the last 50 bytes of $z?
A: If you are that far, you are very close.

Q: Is it legal?
A: That depends on your national legislation. In some parts of the world, the
screenshot may be considered a copyright circumvention device, and you may
not be allowed to view, select, copy, paste, save or print the output of the
program, which itself you may not be allowed to obtain, own, run, reverse
engineer, make available or even talk about. In case you are in doubt, it is
recommended that you contact a local law office.

Q: Why is the screenshot called The Conceptual Crisis of Private Property as a
Crisis in Practice?
A: The title is derived from a quote from Empire by Michael Hardt and Antonio
Negri: "The conceptual crisis of private property does not become a crisis in
practice, and instead the regime of private expropriation has tended to be
applied universally." (page 302)

Q: Why does the screenshot contain the novel Cryptonomicon?
A: Neal Stephenson's novel not only deals with cryptography, but was actually
subject to U.S. export restrictions since it contained a cryptographic
algorithm that was considered a trade secret.

Q: Why was the the screenshot taken on Tuesday, April 20, at 11:57:20 AM?
A: The desktop background is based on a video still that was taken at that date
and time, in 1999.

Q: What is the software shown in the dock?
A: From left to right: Mac OS X Finder, Adobe Acrobat Reader, BBEdit, Apple
QuickTime, CopyLeft, Rolux Reader, Apple FireWire Manager, Microsoft
PowerPoint, Apple LiveType, Opera, Netscape, Mozilla, Apple NetInfo Manager
and Mac OS X Trash.

Q: What additional software do I need to exactly recreate the screenshot?
A: Mac OS X 10.2 (quite obviously), TinkerTool (to change the number of lines
for file names in icon view from 2 to 3), TransparentDock (to adjust the dock
transparency) and Snapz Pro X (to take the screenshot). You will also have to
edit /System/Library/CoreServices/Menu Extras/Clock.menu/Contents/Resources/
English.lproj/Localizable.strings and set "MBC_CLOCK_FORMAT_STRING" to
"%a %b %e %time%p" (to adjust the date format displayed in the menu bar).

Q: Will I be able to transform the recreated screenshot into Cryptonomicon?
A: Not unless you make significant modifications to crisis.php.

Q: How do i find the original screenshot on filesharing networks?
A: Just search for "crisis.png". The size of the file should be 1,476,639 bytes.
Once you have downloaded it, please don't forget to share it.


BIOGRAPHY
---------

Robert Luxemburg, born in 1972 in Bielefeld/Germany, college/university in
Paris, Berlin and New York, lives in Berlin, working as a writer, programmer and
artist.

Software Projects (selection): rolux.org (1998), Rolux Internet Implorer (1999),
Rolux Minordomo (2000), Project GNUtenberg (2000), textz.com (2000), walser.php
(2002), DePNG (2003), SPIEGELstudien (2003)

Video Works (selection): Die Kinder von Godard und Coca-Cola (1998), Drei
Farben: Schwarz Rot Gold (1999), Deutschland gegen die Geschichte (1999), Die
Negation und der Konsum in der Kultur (2000), Millennium (2001), Betacity
(2002), Burn Hollywood Burn (2003)

Group Exhibitions & Festival Contributions (selection): The Thing, New York
(2001), Kurzfilmfestival, Oberhausen (2002), PS1, New York (2002), Cinematexas,
Austin (2002), Kunstwerke, Berlin (2003), Kunsthalle Exnergasse, Vienna (2004),
Transmediale, Berlin (2004), Runtime Art, Zagreb (2004), Free Bitflows, Vienna
(2004)